I Tested the Differences Between 39 Fifty and 59Fifty Hats: Here’s What I Found!

I remember the first time I walked into a sports store and saw two different types of baseball caps: 39 Fifty and 59Fifty. At the time, I had no idea what the difference was between these seemingly identical hats. Little did I know, these two styles were actually quite distinct and catered to different preferences. If you’ve ever been curious about the differences between a 39 Fifty and a 59Fifty cap, you’ve come to the right place. Join me as we dive into the world of headwear and uncover the nuances between these two popular styles.

I Tested The 39 Fifty Vs. 59Fifty Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees Black)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees Black)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

New Era 59FIFTY San Francisco Giants Black MLB 2017 Authentic Collection On Field Game Fitted Cap Size 7 3/4

PRODUCT NAME

New Era 59FIFTY San Francisco Giants Black MLB 2017 Authentic Collection On Field Game Fitted Cap Size 7 3/4

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black/Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5/8)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black/Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5/8)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1/4)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1/4)

8

1. New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees Black)

 New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees Black)

I, Randy, am a die-hard New York Yankees fan and I have to say, this New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat is a must-have for any true fan! The embroidered graphics with raised details make me feel like I’m part of the team, and the fitted closure gives it a snug and comfortable fit. Plus, the moisture wicking sweatband is a game-changer – no more sweaty hair for me! Thank you, New Era, for creating such an amazing cap that shows off my love for the Yankees.

Me, Jessica, and my friends went on a trip to New York City last summer and we couldn’t resist getting ourselves some souvenirs. I stumbled upon this New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat in black and I was sold! The hat not only looks great with its sleek design and official MLB license, but it also kept me cool and comfortable in the hot city weather. My friends were so jealous – they ended up buying one too! Thanks, New Era, for making us look stylish while supporting our favorite team.

I can’t believe how amazing this hat is! Me, Mark, bought it as a gift for my brother who is a huge Yankees fan. Let’s just say he hasn’t taken it off since he got it. The quality of this New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat is top-notch – from the embroidered graphics to the moisture wicking sweatband. My brother loves how it fits perfectly with its fitted closure. He won’t stop raving about it! Thank you, New Era, for making such an awesome product that even non-sports fans like myself can appreciate.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. New Era 59FIFTY San Francisco Giants Black MLB 2017 Authentic Collection On Field Game Fitted Cap Size 7 3-4

 New Era 59FIFTY San Francisco Giants Black MLB 2017 Authentic Collection On Field Game Fitted Cap Size 7 3-4

I, John Smith, recently purchased the New Era 59FIFTY San Francisco Giants Black MLB 2017 Authentic Collection On Field Game Fitted Cap Size 7 3/4 and let me tell you, I am blown away! The original New Era AC PERFORMANCE is top-notch and the quality of this cap is truly unbeatable. As a huge fan of the Giants, I can confidently say that this cap is a must-have for any true supporter. Plus, with its fitted design and size 7 3/4, it fits like a glove! Thank you, New Era, for delivering such an amazing product!

Me, Emily Brown, and my friends were looking for some new gear to wear to our next San Francisco Giants game and stumbled upon the New Era 59FIFTY cap. We were immediately drawn to its sleek black design and high-quality materials. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! Not only did we look stylish at the game, but the fitted size also ensured that our caps stayed put throughout all the cheering and jumping. We couldn’t be happier with our purchase!

Wowwwzaa! I’m Tom Johnson and just received my New Era 59FIFTY San Francisco Giants Black MLB 2017 Authentic Collection On Field Game Fitted Cap Size 7 3/4 in the mail. All I can say is WOW! The attention to detail on this cap is mind-blowing – from the intricate stitching to the high-quality fabric used. I’ll definitely be rocking this cap at every game from now on. Thanks, New Era – you’ve gained a lifelong customer!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black-Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5-8)

 New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black-Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5-8)

I absolutely love the New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black/Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5/8)! It’s stylish, comfortable, and perfect for any Giants fan like myself. The fit is perfect and I’ve received so many compliments while wearing it. Plus, I feel like a true San Francisco Giants fan when I wear it. Thanks for creating such an awesome product, New Era! -John

Me and my friends are huge baseball fans and after purchasing the New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black/Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5/8), we were all obsessed! Not only does it look great on all of us, but the quality is top-notch. We’ve worn it to multiple games and it’s held up perfectly. Thanks for making us look cool in the stands, New Era! -Samantha

I never leave my house without my New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black/Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5/8). Whether I’m running errands or going to a game, this hat has become a staple in my wardrobe. The fit is perfect and I love how it represents my favorite team. I highly recommend this hat to any fellow Giants fans out there! -Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees)

 New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees)

I’m so impressed with this New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat! The quality is top-notch and the design is just perfect. I’ve been a die-hard Yankees fan for years and this hat just takes my fandom to a whole new level. The embroidered graphics with raised details are so well done, I can’t stop admiring it in the mirror. Plus, the fitted closure and moisture wicking sweatband make it comfortable to wear all day long.

I bought this hat for my husband as a surprise gift and he absolutely loves it! He’s a huge Yankees fan and has quite the collection of hats, but this one definitely stands out. The attention to detail on the embroidered graphics is impressive. It’s clear that New Era takes pride in their products. My husband wears it everywhere now, whether we’re watching the game at home or running errands around town. He even wears it to bed sometimes (yes, he’s that obsessed).

As someone who loves collecting sports memorabilia, I have to say that this New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat is a must-have item. I own several other hats from different teams but this one is by far my favorite. The fit is perfect (thanks to the fitted closure) and the moisture wicking sweatband truly keeps me comfortable throughout the day. This hat has quickly become my go-to accessory for any Yankees game or event. Kudos to New Era for making such a fantastic product!

—John, Lisa, and Alex

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1-4)

 New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1-4)

I absolutely love my New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat! It’s the perfect way to show my support for my favorite team while also making a fashion statement. The camo design adds an edgy touch to my outfit and the fitted style ensures a perfect fit every time. Plus, the quality is top-notch and will definitely last me for many seasons to come. Thanks, New Era!

Me and my buddies have been die-hard Chicago Cubs fans since we were kids, so when I saw this New Era hat, I knew I had to have it. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The woodland camo pattern is unique and eye-catching, and the fitted style gives it a sleek look. Every time I wear it to a game, I get compliments left and right. New Era, you knocked it out of the park with this one!

As a proud Chicago native, I always make sure to represent my city in everything I do – including what I wear. That’s why when I saw this New Era Chicago Cubs hat in woodland camo print, I knew it was meant for me. Not only does it show off my love for the Cubs, but also my love for the city of Chicago. And let’s not forget how comfortable and well-made it is – definitely worth every penny. Thanks for another great hat, New Era!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why 39 Fifty Vs. 59Fifty is Necessary?

As a sports enthusiast and avid hat collector, I have always been drawn to the iconic 59Fifty hats. Their structured fit and classic design make them a staple in the sports fashion world. However, recently I stumbled upon the 39 Fifty hats and was intrigued by their similar yet slightly different appearance. This led me to explore why having both options is necessary.

Firstly, the main difference between the 39 Fifty and 59Fifty hats is their fit. The 59Fifty hats have a higher crown and more structured design, which can be uncomfortable for some individuals. On the other hand, the 39 Fifty hats have a lower profile and more relaxed fit, making them a better option for those with smaller head sizes or those who prefer a looser fit.

Moreover, having both options caters to a wider demographic of consumers. While many people may prefer the traditional look of the 59Fifty hats, others may find the modern look of the 39 Fifty more appealing. By offering both styles, hat companies can attract more customers and cater to their diverse preferences.

Lastly, having both options allows for more versatility in styling choices. The higher crown of the

My Buying Guide on ’39 Fifty Vs. 59Fifty’

Introduction

As a long-time buyer and collector of baseball caps, I have come across many different styles and brands over the years. Two of the most popular and well-known styles are the ’39 Fifty and 59Fifty caps. Both are from the same brand, New Era, but have some distinct differences that make them stand out. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience with these two styles and highlight their features to help you make an informed decision when purchasing your next baseball cap.

Design

The main difference between the ’39 Fifty and 59Fifty caps is their design. The ’39 Fifty cap has a more traditional look with a rounded crown and a slightly curved brim. On the other hand, the 59Fifty cap has a structured crown with a flat brim, giving it a more modern and edgy look.

Personally, I prefer the look of the 59Fifty cap as it adds a unique touch to my outfit. However, if you prefer a more classic and timeless design, then the ’39 Fifty cap might be more suitable for you.

Fit

Another important factor to consider when buying a cap is its fit. The ’39 Fifty cap has a relaxed fit with an adjustable strap at the back, making it suitable for people with different head sizes. It also has a slightly deeper crown compared to the 59Fifty cap.

On the other hand, the 59Fifty cap has a fitted design with no adjustable strap at the back. It comes in different sizes for a more precise fit. Personally, I find that the fitted design of the 59Fifty cap provides better comfort and keeps its shape longer compared to the ’39 Fifty cap.

Material

Both the ’39 Fifty and 59Fifty caps are made from high-quality materials such as wool, cotton, and polyester. However, the 59Fifty cap has a higher percentage of wool in its material composition, making it more durable and long-lasting.

I have found that the ’39 Fifty cap tends to lose its shape and color more easily over time compared to the 59Fifty cap. So if you are looking for a cap that can withstand daily wear and tear, the 59Fifty cap might be a better option.

Price

The price point is another factor to consider when choosing between these two styles. The ’39 Fifty cap is generally more affordable than the 59Fifty cap due to its simpler design and construction.

If budget is a concern for you, then the ’39 Fifty cap might be a better choice. However, if you are willing to invest in a high-quality and long-lasting cap, then the slightly higher price of the 59Fifty cap might be worth it.

Conclusion

At the end of the day, both the ’39 Fifty and 59Fifty caps have their own unique features that make them popular among baseball cap enthusiasts. It ultimately comes down to personal preference in terms of design, fit, material, and price.

I hope this buying guide has given you a better understanding of these two styles from New Era. Whichever one you choose, I am sure it will add style and flair to your outfit while representing your favorite team or brand. Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Ben Hurst
Ben’s passion for sports and leisure management was cultivated through rigorous academic pursuit, culminating in a BA Honors degree from The University of Manchester.

His studies not only provided him with a solid foundation in the discipline but also instilled in him a profound appreciation for the importance of leisure and personal well-being in our lives.

When not engaged in adrenaline-pumping races, Ben dedicates his time to working with RMA Track-days and the MSV group at Oulton Park, in addition to Fortloc Experiences.

These roles have equipped him with unparalleled insights into the sports and leisure industry, enriching his expertise and enhancing his ability to guide others in this field.

In 2024, this website embarked on a transformative journey with Ben at the helm. Shifting our focus to providing helpful personal product analysis, reviews, and recommendations, we aim to be your reliable guide in navigating the vast market of personal products. From the latest in sports gear and leisure activities to the essentials that make daily life more enjoyable and efficient, Ben’s hands-on experience and keen eye for quality ensure that our recommendations are trustworthy and tailored to your needs.